Browse reviews

Brighton Year-Round 2026

The Importance of Being Earnest

New Venture Theatre, Brighton

Genre: classical, Comedy, Costume, Drama, LGBT, Theatre

Venue: New Venture Theatre Upstairs

Festival:


Low Down

Director Ayshen Irfan resists updating Earnest – with one tiny exception – in her full-length play debut at Brighton’s New Venture Theatre Upstairs till November 14.

If there is a returns ticket on any night, grab!

Review

There’s no contest. 131 years after Wilde’s The Importance of Being Earnest transported its first Victorian audience on St Valentine’s Day 1895, it’s never needed updating. A few got most of its jokes then. Many more of us get them now. But still it ambushes us, still proves us out of date. Pulsing from exquisite aspic it anticipates every queer, subversive, socialist and anarchic theatre of the next century and more. It’s even outlasted Stoppard’s take in his 1975 Travesties. That’s why director Ayshen Irfan resists updating Earnest – with one tiny exception – in her full-length play debut at Brighton’s New Venture Theatre Upstairs till November 14.

That exception has its roots in the 1890s too: Charly’s Aunt from 1892. That’s to anticipate. The stylish production itself triumphs over the very sad withdrawal of Bertie Purchese as Algernon, due to illness. He’s replaced at incredibly short notice by Sam Razavi, who excels here in every nuance of Algernon Moncrieff. It’s also meant the first part of the run had to be cancelled, making one of the hottest seats in NVT’s recent history, regrettably even hotter.

Vocally this production is pitch-perfect, and for a couple of reasons that’s remarkable. Beyond this though, the pauses, gestures, tilt of head of principal actors render this one of the most gesturally exquisite productions I’ve seen at NVT. Everything in Earnest is how the surface gleam must blind you, just for a moment. Then the barbs strike like sunlight in your face. Wilde’s inversions do heavy lifting and back-flips: the lower orders setting an example, the acts of violence education encourages. Then there’s the nonchalance of Lane’s and Merriman’s treatment by their superiors. Paul Trudgian’s imperturbable double-role fills with suppressed dignity and silent reproof: these all lurk behind each airy dismissal, or even the way the servant doesn’t need to be told to vanish. Even Lane’s ready explanation of ”ready money” and cucumbers, for which he’ll never get any thanks from Algernon – who consumed them – are never pointed up. They don’t need to be. Naturalism points itself; Irfan and her team allow this to breathe.

It’s there for instance in self-parody. When Jack Worthing (Jon Cottrell) arrives with a nose-sniff in the air in funereal garb (shout out to Gaby Bowring and Gladrags) there’s the very carriage of grief: for a man who never existed. Or will he? Cottrell assumes command with a cut-glass look and a crispness to his cuff-links. His pauses and sidelong looks set the tone as Razavi assumes a more louche and scampish irresponsibility, born of privilege and not having the same limited cares as Jack: their flirting is nuanced, their playfulness full of sexual subtext that’s never allowed to make us believe they prefer each other entirely, to the women they pursue (or are pursued by). Razavi has caught up the gauntlet and it fits perfectly.

The other ambush is Jeremy Crow’s Lady Bracknell. Crow’s stentorian voice can cut through blast walls, so his quietly chiselled voice is a revelation here. Not only does he rarely need to raise it above a low command, his full volume is only ever used twice: and not where you expect it. The handbag delivery is a gem, but so is Crow’s porting the empurpled Bracknell back and forth across the rails of command.

Gwendolen Fairfax (Isabelle Boreham) is as you’d expect with this actor, a delight of delivery, timing and expression: especially in full glare. Her poise with Cottrell is complete: the way she and later Joanna-Joy Salter’s Cicely thrust down their suitors to one knee multiple times is a neat inversion Irfan and her cast adopt throughout. This is a quietly feminist rewrite of direction. Nothing obtrusive, but here the foot is definitely on the suitors’ necks. You feel that Gwendolen is to a degree her mother’s daughter.

Salter’s Cecily Cardew contrasts with sheer exuberant girlishness: you believe she’s 18, a little giddier and more prone to a fight than Boreham’s adamantine “I have never seen a shovel” Gwendolen. Salter brings a pointed, winning petulance to her “horrid political economy” and her playing with Razavi’s Algernon.

Sarah Donnelly makes of Miss Prism a less prissy, warmer tutor than usual: so you believe Ben Pritchard’s convincingly bass-voiced, even virile Dr Chasuble is capable of scooping her up which (spoiler) he does. Pritchard – marking 20 years with NVT –  dons the rich-toned unctuousness of someone you don’t mess with about canon law; and makes him more substantial. Donnelly too manages superbly drawn-out hesitations as the full terror of Bracknell and possible retribution looms. And her frozen horror when Jack mistakes her relation to him.

Michael Foulkard’s set is classic Earnest, allowing actors to breathe and let their gestures land. Classically lit too by Ewan Cassidy with numinous gestures to bright windows, the distance and offstage, the set’s palette is realised in glowing pastel colours: Algernon’s town house rooms, the Manor House garden, its library.  Brief set-changes are well-managed, with the curtains closing round the muffin-eating men for the opening of Act Three.

Another shout for Ian Black and Chris Dent’s sound: whoever recorded ‘Daisy, Daisy’ like a demented wrong-note rag has to be applauded, and all the other pianistic manglings an offstage Jack inflicts. Only with the (just about) contemporary Scott Joplin does music find itself.

In every way first-class, this two-and-a-half-hour production is also how the shock of the old is allowed to strike us through a transparent reading by Irfan we’re too infrequently entertained by. Hers is an exceptional, selfless debut: though huge credit to her cast and creatives – and Razavi for stepping in at unbelievably short notice. If there is a returns ticket on any night, grab!

 

 

Production Manager Tamsin Mastoris

Stage Managers Bryony Weaver

ASMs Natalie Sack-Hammond, Leon Batuah, Linda Rothwell, Justin Finklestein, Chris De La Nougerede Tess Baber, Richard Lock, Gaby Bowring, Chris Dent, Guy Dixon

Set Design Michael Foulkard

Set Team Leader Simon Glazier

Set Construction Simon Glazier, Pete Ranson, Justin Finklestein

Set Painting Michael Foulkard, Chris De La Nougerede, Charly Somers, Bryony Weaver, Annie Shepherd

Costume Design Gaby Bowring

Makeup Richi Blennerhassett

Lighting Design Ewan Cassidy

Lighting Rigging Ewan Cassidy, Chris Dent, Bert Gladstone, Chris Phipps

Lighting Operators Alex Epps, Chris Phipps

Sound Design Ian Black, Chris Dent

Sound Operation Chris Dent, Sabrina Giles

Poster Strat Mastoris, Tamsin Mastoris

Programme Design Tamsin Mastoris

Photography Strat Mastoris

Marketing and Publicity Emmie Spencer, Elysa Hyde

Props Bryony Weaver

Health & Safety Ian Black, Richard Lock.

Special thanks to Charly Somers for help and support, Steve Hoard for the music, Emmaus Sussex, Varia, Idgie, Cherry and the Sewing Team at Gladrags, Lyn from Henfield Theatre Company. FOH and Box Office. And above all Katie Brownings.

Published