FringeReview UK 2026
Desire Under the Elms
Almeida Theatre

Genre: American Theater, Costume, Drama, Live Music, Mainstream Theatre, Theatre, Tragedy
Venue: Almeida Theatre, Islington
Festival: FringeReview UK
Low Down
O’Neill’s Desire Under the Elms directed at the Almeida by Ebenezer Bamgboye till December 23 is also here given much of O’Neill’s expressionist edge, despite being one of his realist plays.
A must-see. Partly for the flawed but elemental play itself; with Antony Byrne supporting, and particularly Zakary Momoh’s sizzling chemistry with Kelly Gough. But particularly for Gough’s anguished towering performance which deserves an award.
Review
It’s hard to imagine American theatre before this indelibly powerful if flawed work. And that it was the greatest American tragedy, indeed play ever written when it opened in 1924. O’Neill’s Desire Under the Elms directed at the Almeida by Ebenezer Bamgboye till December 23 is also here given much of O’Neill’s expressionist edge, despite being one of his realist plays. His experiments were necessary to him, as Martin Seymour-Smith wrote: but he always returned to realism for his greatest work. Bamgboye has combined both. It’s an ingenious response.
Admittedly it breathes with what seems (at first) a homage to Rebecca Frecknall’s – and Almeida house – aesthetic: from the 2018 production of Summer and Smoke onwards. Stripped-back brickwork, bare stage where Basia Binkowska’s set responds to some of O’Neill’s non-naturalistic directions (rooms like the four chambers of the heart). Camilla Dely’s costumes foreground the grime, though the overwhelming effect is Jack Knowles’ lighting; with his spectral trademarks of edges glinting here softened to the seraphic. Unusually though there’s cross-glare moments of red gridded with red floodlights. George Dennis’ sound hammers XANA’s composition and musical direction and design.
Bamgboye ensures the opening though is striking: with all the peripheral characters not integral to the tragedy, a Greek chorus, referencing O’Neill’s conscious assumption of Greek tragedy (no spoilers as to which ones). Three Sprits like a chorus emerge: singer Choolwe Laina Muntanga rises powerfully with XANA’s version of ‘The House of the Rising Sun’ almost unrecognizable till the central section. Tendai Humphrey Sitima on guitar, Nathaniel Wade on trumpet all appear later on as revenants. Two elder brothers of the farm owner discuss their chances. Jamie Beamish’s shrewd peace-making, power-broking Simeon reins in the stupidities of Thomas Coombes’ larky, lusty, impulsively mean Peter. Though there’s occasional speed-runs and flickers of violence in Sam Lyon-Behan’s fight direction, it’s mainly Rose Ryan’s movement and intimacy that dominates: slowed-down, aching, heavily ritualised in an expressionist manner, full of portent.
It’s the early 1900s in the South, not the original 1850 in the north-east. It works well. Everyone in the family is invested in owning the farm, or being excluded. Younger brother Eben (Zakary Momoh) arrives and proposes his elder half-brothers give up their share of it. He’s seen their father about to return with a young bride. In return he’ll give them all the money he saved. Seeing the couple approach the brothers gleefully assent; and depart with gleeful curses to some update of 1850 California gold-prospecting. After this five actors (bar Muntanga to a degree) merely swell a party scene. Everything concentrates on just three characters: the quintessence of Greek tragedy.
Antony Byrne’s Ephraim arrives full of menace and quick curses to his two departing sons, with contempt engrained on his face for Eben. Byrne’s tongue flickers like a snake as he fawns over Kelly Gough’s Abbie. Tension rachets as even and Abbie circle each other with mistrust (each thinks the other will cheat them out of the arm) and Abbie’s talking of “my farm” hardly endears her, even to Ephraim. Yet clearly the younger pair are attracted, and neither know how to negotiate it. Whilst Abbie invites Eben, his hesitations even cause her to denounce him, but nothing can withstand their riveting desire.
Byrne’s performance is all you could wish of hunch and ferocity. He mightn’t be the most dangerous or lowering physically, but semaphores a killer instinct his violence can make bad, as it were. By contrast his sugary attempts to woo Abbie long after marriage are properly glutinous, yet edged into lust with possession but ultimate contempt. Momoh’s wired with stalking around Gough like some tethered ghost. His delivery mixes sharp articulate speech with a vocal undertow almost like a subtext of dread. He’s quietly mesmerising.
Gough though is extraordinary. From initial mean-speaking defensiveness, mixed with derisory come-ons braced for rejection, she exudes Abbie’s hard living, one with no expectations, who’s miraculously landed a secure berth. And will fight to the death for it. The way the paid ease and edge up to their desire, and take off their mutual rasp is slowed down by Ryan’s way of making them pulse, circle and freeze love. The climax in this Freudian drama occurs where the two meet in Eben’s mother’s sealed bedroom. Epharim worked both his wives to death and Eben’s haunted by his mother as Muntanga appears, almost tpo bless the union. Suddnely in the second half and just as O’Neill directs, Gough’s tight-bound hair is loosed and so are Abbie’s emotions, Gough scorches the heavens with passion and ultimately screaming.
The consequences of the couple’s passion – by now of nearly a year’s standing – impel them differently. Eben for some reason is still unconvinced that Abbie’s not stealing the farm, and she decides on a drastic gesture. Though the power of this scene is overwhelming – and it’s literally demonic with shafts of red and white light, and revenants presiding – it’s O’Neill at fault here. And Bamgboye should be given real credit for swerving one final gesture from Eben that’s not believable. In that way, he’s actually improved on O’Neill. Elsewhere, it’s debatable whether importing O’Neil’s expressionist self is necessary. It also seems designed round that extraordinary climactic scene which suggests horror.
This visceral production’s reach might exceed its grasp, but what’s theatre for? A bold stripping-back to O’Neill’s Greek ambitions, it exposes both his pretension and power. Nevertheless, this is a must-see, with its two-hours-forty calibrated slow-burn. Partly for the flawed but elemental play itself; with Byrne supporting, and particularly Momoh’s sizzling chemistry with Gough. But particularly for Gough’s anguished, towering performance which deserves an award.
Casting Director Julia Horan CDG, Fight Director Sam Lyon-Behan, Voice Coach Kara Tsiaparas, Costume Supervisor Heidi Bryan, Wigs, Hair & Make-Up Supervisor Casey Martin, Assistant Director Maxi Himpe, Sound Associate Michael Woods, Music Associate Ashely Blasse. Artwork Photography Nadav Kander.























